374 People Offered Him an Intro. Nobody Followed Up.

Susan Frew • November 12, 2026

Share this article

A 15-minute list check with the AI you already have. Nothing to buy.

Quick take

  • Your next customer is probably already in your files. They just have not heard from you.
  • Export your list, hand it to AI, and ask one question: who did I go quiet on?
  • AI drafts a personal note for each person. You read it, fix it, and hit send.
  • Fifteen minutes. The step-by-step and both prompts are in the download.

Watch Gerry find his 374

Watch Gerry walk through his dashboard, or read the steps below. Both get you to the same place.

In October 2026, my team and I found 1,900 people who subscribed to this newsletter and never made it into the email system I send it from.

So hey, if you did not get a newsletter from me over the last year, this is why!

Nineteen hundred people raised their hand and I left them standing there. And I teach this stuff.

I am not the only one. Gerry O'Brion, who runs What Big Brands Know, had leads on paper, in spreadsheets, in folders, and in a CRM he says he "sorta" uses. He had AI pull all of it into one dashboard: 4,693 people. In there were 374 people who had offered to introduce him to an event or a company, 71 of them in the last couple of years. Follow-up, in his words, is the thing he is not good at. Now AI drafts the notes, he reads and fixes each one, and he sends 15 a day, three days a week. In the video he shows you the dashboard.

Neither of us needed new leads. We needed to look in our own couch cushions.

Year end is the perfect time. Budgets are closing, calendars are opening, and "I was thinking of you" lands better in November than in January.

Here is the whole job.

How to Use AI to Find Quiet Customers and Win Them Back

1. Export your list

Pull your customers out of wherever they live: your CRM, your invoicing tool, or your email contacts. You want name, email, what they bought or asked about, and the date you last talked. A spreadsheet is perfect.

2. Ask AI who went quiet

Upload the file to the AI tool you already use and paste in Prompt 1 from the download. It sorts your list into three piles: past customers you have not contacted in six months, people who asked you for something and never got an answer, and people who offered you a referral or an intro.

3. Pick your top 15

Ask AI to rank the piles by who is most likely to say yes, and to tell you why for each one. You know these people. Overrule it wherever your gut disagrees.

4. Draft a personal note for each one

Paste in Prompt 2. Each note names the last thing you did together, makes one ask, and stays under 90 words. No "just checking in." Nobody has ever been happy to be checked in on.

5. Read, fix, and send five a day

You send these yourself, from your own inbox, after you read every word. AI does the digging and the first draft. You do the relationship.

Grab the step-by-step and both prompts

Try It Yourself

No time for the whole list? Open your sent folder, find three customers you have not emailed since summer, and have AI draft a note to each. Ten minutes. Three doors reopened.

One caution before you upload: a customer list is private data. Use a paid or business AI plan, or turn off the setting that lets the tool train on your data. Thirty seconds, and worth it.

This is what I mean in Recoded when I say AI should upgrade your business DNA. It does not need to find you strangers. It can help you take better care of the people who already said yes.

Want Help Handing AI the Next Jobs?

The win-back is one job you can give AI today. In Give AI a Job, you hand it at least three, and they are running in your business by the last session. I teach it live and we build on your business, not a pretend one.

  • Four live 90-minute sessions on Zoom, all recorded
  • A library of 40+ prompts, customized for your industry
  • A 90-day roadmap you write and I review
  • Open to owners and leaders in any industry

No pressure, no countdown clock, just a seat if you want one.

Grab a seat in the next cohort

If you'd rather talk first, you can also book a free 30-minute AI Evaluation.

Go find your 1,900.

— Susan


Recent Posts

Susan Frew video on five tech outages in eight days
By Susan Frew • November 19, 2026
Microsoft 365, the FAA, Chase and Apple all went down in eight days, and none were hacks. Here's the small business lesson and a free AI prompt for your Plan B.
Title card: AI Is a Great Stylist. It's a Lousy Friend.
By Susan Frew • October 29, 2026
My AI gave me a 10 out of 10 on an orange jacket. Here's why that worries me, what the JED Foundation research shows, and a free 20-minute AI stylist handout.
Title card: Four AI Assistants Are Already Living Inside Your Browser
By Susan Frew • October 22, 2026
ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, and Copilot already live in your browser. Here is how to use them on your open tabs, plus official links and a free cheat sheet.
Title card: This Week's AI Drops, Sorted by What You Pay For
By Susan Frew • October 8, 2026
OpenAI, Google, and Anthropic all shipped in eight days. Here is who gets Dots, Gemini 4 Argon, and Claude Sonnet 5.5 on each plan, plus a free cheat sheet.
Title card: I Hired 11 Employees. None of Them Eat Lunch.
By Susan Frew • September 30, 2026
I built an AI org chart with 11 named agents. Two are already live, and a human still checks everything. Here's the six-line job description and a free worksheet.
Title card: The Facts Behind the September 2026 AI Panic
By Susan Frew • September 17, 2026
A researcher resigned from Anthropic, a DeepMind researcher followed, and Dario Amodei published a new essay. Here are the facts, sources, and what I would do.
Title card: Set It Once. Your AI Remembers Everywhere.
By Susan Frew • September 11, 2026
Google expanded Gemini custom instructions across Workspace. Tell it who you are once, and it uses your voice in Gmail, Docs, Drive, Chat, Sheets, and Slides.
Title card: I Let Claude Click Around Without Me
By Susan Frew • September 3, 2026
Claude in Chrome can now act on its own, with a safety check on every click. Here's how to try it carefully, flip the toggle, and keep control of the keys.
Title card: One Click, One Video, Zero Extra Software
By Susan Frew • August 27, 2026
Google built a Record button into Slides through Google Vids. Talk through a deck, fix flubs in the transcript, and send a shareable video with no extra software.
Title card: Desktop? App? Browser? So Confusing. Are You Using the Wrong Version?
By Susan Frew • August 13, 2026
Claude and ChatGPT each show up in at least four places: web, desktop, mobile, and your browser. Here's how to pick the right one, plus a free one-page map.
Show More